It Happened
by Mary Deborah Alice Bumstead Winans
-One-
Little Mary's Memories
The light from the hall shines into the dark room. Half awake I see the shape of a man, as black as night and as scary as death, framed in the doorway. Then the door is shut and he is inside. I must keep as still as I can. I must not move a single muscle. If I so much as twitch a finger, he will stab me with his knife. My stillness doesn't stop him from coming over to the bed, where he sits down. Startled, I shy like a pony, suddenly, my whole body frightened. I know who it is, I know what will happen, it has happened before, and yet I haven't gotten used to it. In fact, each time is worse than before, as if the worst were yet to come, the whole building up to some horrible conclusion. I want to run, back to Mama or Daddy who are sitting unaware in Grandbee and Grandpa's living room, so close I can hear them talking. Why don't they come to help me? But the barriers of doors, closet, bathroom, hallway, kitchen, and most of all the barriers of his hands, his voice, keep me imprisoned.
Uncle Hersey says things like, “Little Mary, I won't hurt you.” What a lie. He pinches me sometimes, that hurts. He pushes, he prods in tender places, that hurts. He says, “Be still, you can't go to Mama now. Look, I'm going to show you something,” or he says, “Be as quiet as you can, don't cry. I can hurt you if I have to,” or “Let me pull your pants down, what a good girl, Mary,” and “Remember, never tell anyone I came in here; it's a secret, and I can hurt you if you tell.” All in his gentle smiling voice, whispery, but scary, so scary a big balloon of darkness fills up my chest with fear. I am frozen in fear, waiting for the end.
This is what he does:he pulls my shirt up high under my arms and rubs my chest, pinches my nipples, even puts his lips down on me, licking me. He pulls my pants and panties off completely. I know now he will rub my thighs, push and pull at my skin, and wiggle his fingers into my little places. I hate how he cares so much for my bottom parts, how he ignores my eyes. He doesn't care about me up in my mind at all. All he wants are my thighs open. Over and over I try to shut them, and he pushes them open. I can't stand it. I want to go away. I want to go far far away. At the same time my body reaches out without my permission. It likes the feeling between my legs, the smoothing of his hands on my skin, his tongue licking me, as if I were a kitten. What am I supposed to do about my body, how do I keep it from becoming part of him and his ways, when the rest of me wants to escape?
He makes noises that scare me, too. Why is he sounding so strange? And then I open my eyes sometimes, and see the giant poking thing that he keeps in his pants behind a zipper. The belt loosens, I can hear it, the zipper comes down, I can hear it. Then I peek as hard as I can, wondering. But it is more than I can bear when he lifts me up and sets me on his lap and puts the poking thing against my tummy. How hard it is, how strange it is. He wants me to hold it, but I can't because I'm not there anymore. I'm completely limp. I can't bear it one bit longer. I'm just waiting for some other world to come into my life and set me free.
*
I am Little Mary, so young my memories are patchy. But I know now Uncle Hersey had been close to us since before my big brothers were born. He admitted years later that he had even abused his little brother, my Daddy, when they were kids. My brothers probably were victims, too, but I don't know, as no one will talk about it now. I think I can feel that Uncle Hersey's been at me since I was a baby of one or two. Most memories are gone from those alive, or gone in every sense from those who have died. I look at a photo of my family standing next to him, circa 1957: he's smiling there like the good brother of my Daddy that everyone thinks he is, while I am clinging to my Daddy's leg, turned away, hiding my face from the uncle with my other hand, frowning in the sunshine, barely three years old. I really don't know how many times he has found me, in one house, or another, or another. Mostly at Grandbee's in the country where each week we gather, eat, play, hike in the hills, have glorious fun with aunts, uncles, cousins galore, and into the evening the adults talking, talking, and me, the littlest girl, sleepy, dropping off, and being put down to sleep alone in Grandbee and Grandpa's bedroom.
But I remember once, at his own house in the city, I stay the night with my favorite cousin. He sneaks in, into the fairy tale bedroom nook my cousin has for all her own, that I'd been excited to sleep in with her. His dark villainous shadow creeps in, staining my love and excitement with fear. My cousin knows, oh how she knows about her own dad. It has happened to her innumerable times, but now she's too old. He likes me now, and pushes her away in anger as she tries to save me.
And now I am six and he has finagled a way to find me in my own home. This is the way he did it: He got a deal on a house out on State Street in our town. He bought the house and he told his brother, my Daddy, that wouldn't it be good if Daddy could come fix up the house, wouldn't it be fine if Daddy and Daddy's family moved into the new house, and Daddy worked on it for free rent? Then Daddy and Mama could rent their little old house on Buena Vista for some extra cash. Oh, what a clever idea, and of course, he had to stay weekends at the house with us, too, to help. It was way too far to go to his home in the city each night.
But that first night there, when Mama and Daddy are asleep or busy, I suppose, anyway, where are they all this time, I wonder. Shouldn't they be watching me? Maybe they let him come in to do this to me? Maybe this is part of growing up? No, I don't know, but this time I'm not going to let him get me. Haha, I listen to the footsteps coming along the bare hallway. He's coming, he's coming. My mind darts around like a trapped bunny. And like a bunny I hop up from bed. Silently, I zip away to hide. Haha, he won't find me behind the big boxes in my room, all still unpacked. I creep behind one, crouch into a ball, my heart thudding, my little places throbbing, but me so still, so quiet, as the door opens. There is the light spilling in like always, but he doesn't see me. I'm not there. His voice whispers, threatens. I only roll up tighter into my frozen ball of body. I don't give in. I hide. I hear him come in, but there is a noise in another part of the house. He has to retreat. I've won this time, and that makes me feel strong.
*
It becomes something like a nightmare, happening in the dark, awakening me from sleep, so during the day I forget it and try to feel happy. I love school. Oh, I love my teacher, Mrs. Smith. It is true I was afraid at first. I was afraid of riding the bus from our new home and back, when I had learned to walk to and from kindergarten with my best friend, Annette, last year when we lived on Buena Vista. It is true I was scared of all the new faces; I don't know why, but how much better I felt when they took me from one teacher's classroom into Mrs. Smith's room where Annette was. I heard them discussing it -- “Maybe Mary would do better with her friend in my class,” Mrs. Smith said. I did do better. I began to learn to play. I learned to laugh and have fun. School was joy, and now I know daylight means I can relax. Only good things happen during the day, I'm sure of it now.
That is how it works. Out at Grandbee and Grandpa's the day is full of only fun, good times, with loving Mama and aunts, all so soft and safe, cousins so dusty and noisy and adventurous. Long hikes up the dirt road, picking out walking sticks, that was fun, too, with Daddy along, and quiet Grandpa, even he, Uncle Hersey, seemed almost a safe grown-up, with his smile, his high waisted pants, his talk of God. Only when he laughed did I hear some echo of my fear in the dark room inside me. But I think the daylight time is safe, I'm pretty sure of it.
Until one day. When the adults, all except for him, have gone on a hike, and all the cousins and I are playing rough among the rocks, climbing and hiding and shuffling through the eons of prickly oak leaves. Somehow I've fallen in the leaves, felt almost as if I were drowning in the leaves. I must go in to the bathroom, too, the need presses on me, so I run up the stairs of the pink adobe house we call Sleepy Hollow and cross the kitchen to the bathroom. Ah, how good it feels to pee, but – the door is opening. “I'm in here,” I cry, desperate for privacy. “I know,” his voice says.
“You are covered in leaves,” he says, as I grab up my pants. He sounds just as if he might be Daddy, commenting, and because it is day, I feel maybe I'm safe.
“Wouldn't you like to get cleaned up?” he asks, and I'm still thinking it is all right. Maybe I do need cleaning up, but as he kneels and begins to undo my clothes, dread stiffens me. Now I can not move. What is wrong? Is this the way it is supposed to be? My tummy feels sick, as he holds me close to him and turns on the bathtub water.
Some oak leaves fall into the tub and float like little boats. I stare and stare at the leaves swirling, while his hands explore my bottom, my little parts. He lifts me into the tub, lays me down, right down in the water. It is still only a few inches deep, but down it flows out of the spigot, getting deeper and deeper. Now I'm not drowning in leaves, I'm drowning in water! But he doesn't care. He opens my thighs. I close them, struggle to sit up. He opens them, makes me slip back, water up my nose. He doesn't care! All he wants is down below. He wants my thighs open, my little places to touch. It is daylight, and yet, here he is, the nightmare man of darkness drowning me. Is he trying to kill me? I begin struggling with all my might.
But then he's done. He lifts me out. “Don't tell anyone,” he reminds me. I stand still, shivering, gone completely away from myself. I'm keeping my eyes downcast, but up there in my other mind I'm looking at his zipper and wondering about the thing inside his pants, the thing that hides and then comes out like a dark greedy goblin when he unzips. It is hidden away again. I'd like to study it in private, maybe learn what it is and what it means, maybe touch it or poke it back or bend it or hit it, I don't know what. I want to know it and understand what it wants of me. I'm fascinated by that thing because it seems so important and powerful. Maybe with a thing like that I couldn't be caught like this. I'd be strong all the time, like boys are. And all the while he dries me, dresses me. I'm like a doll, unable to move, unable to do for myself in any way. Today my strength is all gone. He has won for good.
I'm left to go outdoors again, but I don't know what to do. I wander onto the patio, feel the warmth of the day, see the comforting boulders on the hillside, hear the shouts of my brothers and cousins. When the other adults come home from their hike, I want my Mama, I want my Daddy. But even they along with everyone else greet Uncle Hersey as if he were a regular human being. They all believe he is good, kind, Godly, the big brother who succeeds at work as opposed to my Daddy who fails, the one to look up to, the man who does only good in an evil world, the one with the sparkling smile and soft soft voice. They never see the danger, the power and greed behind his smile, the cruelty behind his zipper.
-Two-
True Deborah
Through the years of being battered by Uncle Hersey and his giant thing, Little Mary barely survives. First he had filled her nights with fear, and then he had brought the pain into daylight. But now I am seven, my name is Deborah, and a year full of goodness and joy bursts upon me like a healing light come down from heaven to cure me. Daddy, Mama, my brothers, and I move away from Hemet, move away from my father's side of the family, move away from the darkness that had stalked Little Mary. We travel up to Washington state to rent a home on Puget Sound in the green forests.
I am free to remember my own life, my own loves, my own occupations. Nothing like that creeping fear hurts me here, so I am clean, I am happy, I am truly myself, Deborah, as my family calls me. I am an important little girl with a big name. I prosper. I thrive. I am filled with nature, with blue sea, with good family play. I love school, I love my teacher, Mrs. Taber, I love reading, I love my best friend, Jenny.
Oh, there are dark reminders sometimes. Seeing Daddy in a pair of mustard yellow stretchy swim trunks that show the bulge between his legs, which scares me, reminding me of something I've almost forgotten. The bucket of big clams we dig up in the mud one day – I stare at them soaking in fresh water with their big white wrinkly thing-like appendages hanging out of their ball-shaped shells. Makes me feel funny to see them. They remind me of something and I'm afraid and fascinated at the same time.
Mostly, though, I am free. It feels good to be myself. And this freedom teaches me that I can be strong, I can be successful. I will take this lesson forward. For years to come I will be myself and proud of it. Even when the old trouble hurts me again and again with versions of the same pain, I will still be strong. Even though this cycle repeats in my life, still I can be and I am important, joyful, true Deborah.
-Three-
Debbie/Davey
I don't remember how, now that I'm eight, now we are back from Washington and in Hemet again where I'm called Debbie -- but somehow I know what male genitals look like. I know boys are men, and boys have what men do on their bodies. I'm mighty interested in this. Sometimes I pretend that I could be a boy, but this is separate from my main life as a girl. As a girl, I'm sure I'm going to have lots of children, and I'm going to be a good mama. As a girl, I absolutely love my dolls. I give them lives full of personality and pretend reality, so much so, that they almost seem like real babies. I love dressing up my Betsy McCall doll in the different outfits Mama makes for her; oh, my, those little carefully sewn dresses please me. I want to sew, too, and I begin trying, enjoying it.
As a girl, I play with my girlfriends in girlish ways. I'm horse crazy, as girls sometimes are. Animals are like children, and I want all of them, horses, dogs, cats. I want to learn all the wild creatures' names, too. I love books about animals, about magic and fantasy lands, about families full of real children. I am consumed by life in books; how beautiful the worlds are in my mind when I'm reading a good book.
As a girl I am complete, at least, that is what I think.
But sometimes I like to feel like a boy. I want to call myself Davey and leave Debbie behind for awhile. I feel a grubby boyish brave feeling, a feeling that in daydreams I can go on boy adventures and get loved by grown-ups who love me for being a boy, not a girl. I know boys are more important than girls, is that why I like to daydream I'm a boy sometimes? Or is it because I love my Daddy and want to be like him? Or that I look up to my big brothers and want to be like them? Or that my best friend, Jeff, is a boy, a kind boyish boy just like I would be? Or does it have to do with what Uncle Hersey did to me that causes me to want to have that other life inside me? Does that part of me go back to Uncle Hersey, that is what I really want to know now.
Did his abuse of Little Mary set me up to thinking it'd be better if I were a boy? Seeing his genitals, realizing their power, did that make me want to be strong enough or the same enough to be able to stop him from hurting me? If I were the same as he, maybe he wouldn't hurt me? Later, I find out this wouldn't have made a difference; he abused boys, too. But maybe I thought at the time that being a boy like my Daddy, my brothers, even like Uncle Hersey, might save me, might save my life.
My life as Debbie/Davey is a wonderful full learning feeling life. In a way, though it sounds like it's a sexual thing to want to be a boy part of the time, this duality in me seems more about being everything together that I see all around me, and less about attraction to one sex or another. But it changes as I leave Debbie/Davey behind and enter puberty. Only when I fall in love with a boy my own age and a man, a teacher, in ninth grade does the true sexual girl come into her own importance. As a girl, though I'd been fine, complete in every way, I see now it was in every way but sexual. I still love my dolls, still want to be a mama, still love sewing, horses, reading, caring for animals, playing with girlfriends in girlish ways. Still in all my outer ways, as a girl, I flourish. But now I see that the girl had never known herself as a sexual person. She had been in hiding all those years; I hadn't been able to see her at all. Not until I am 13 does she flood out in the most healthy way, full of desire, all ready to be over Uncle Hersey, to leave him way way behind, to go into good love with potential for good sex between grown good man and grown loving woman.
-Four-
Famous Debbie Bumstead
Finally I'm ready to be over it. I'm ready to grow past the past and open up to who I should be at the age of 13. I am a young teenager wanting to become a woman who will be loved in the right way by a good man. I know what sex is now. I've learned at school how the man's part fits in the woman's part and why I've started having periods.
Now that I'm thirteen, for the first time we have a television at home. I watch lots of shows and movies in which there's romance, kissing and hugging. It looks sweet to me, and seems to easily enter into my daydreams. First there's a boy in 8th grade that I like to look at, a quiet blond handsome boy named Mark. I dare not talk to him, though, still too shy. This shyness has been with me since Little Mary's time. As a little girl it felt like a silent shadow that paralyzed my whole body and my mind when I was confronted by new grown-ups. I was terrified of my friends' parents, of shopkeepers, of anyone unknown. Now my shyness includes the scary teens of my own age.
But still, by ninth grade even shyness isn't keeping me from heading toward healthy growth. I actually flirt with a boy named Rex who is in several of my classes. And my daydreams are full of Mr. Basile, my ninth grade Art teacher. He is dark, but the opposite of tall and handsome, being short and plump with a smallish chin, but looks don't matter in this case, not when one poet recognizes another. Of course, I have no idea of his opinion of me in real life, but he loves me dearly in my daydreams, so much so we are making love in these dreams and having a child -- what beautiful daydreams I have!
And then – I become famous. No, not in my daydreams, but in real life. I am famous within my family as most people are, but I'm also famous with my teachers, famous with my friends, and even famous enough to win awards and scholarships later on. Do you know how much famous people are loved? I do. I'm lucky to be able to paint and become famous as an artist, and I'm lucky to be able to write sensitively about life and nature and become a famous writer. Not many people become famous at such a young age, and those who do are loved so much they blossom into pure joy. They are ready for all good things to happen in the present and future, while the past goes past and disappears.
My English teacher, Miss Kerr, has recognized my writing talent and made me famous, and for that, I've decided to be just like her, if only I were pretty. If only I could dress as prettily as she, be as brave as she, have success at work, as she does. Well, there's still hope, I think. Things are going along; maybe I'll improve in looks and dress. I spend a lot of time planning to look nice, so maybe someday I will. I practice sewing with Mama. Mama is stylish herself and is bound to help me learn.
Fame follows me everywhere! I find a discarded tennis racket on the school campus and begin practicing, until – I am famous on the tennis teams of high school and college! True, I'm not often a winner, but I win sportsmanship awards. And in tennis, I can see something of life more clearly than at any other time. Looking across a court, waiting for a serve, it seems as if I know the truth about time, about here, about now. How can that help me, though, with the darkness still deep inside me?
Because, as always in good years, there are reminders of dark shadows. I begin a ten year long series of nightmares, always about dead babies or kittens. These are so bad I fear going to sleep. Why am I finding little corpses lying on hillsides of green grass? Or seeing a child play by the side of a cliff and then drop suddenly over the edge? Why do I see children's bodies burning in fires? Why do the kittens I should have taken care of end up hanging from crotches of trees, dead? I never understand my nightmares, but now I wonder: did they have to do with Little Mary struggling to survive and failing as I grew into a woman? Was she trying to tell me something or bring herself into my memory for some reason? I don't know.
The other pain that never lets me go from age 13 to 43, when it is so bad I have to have a hysterectomy, is the monthly agony of cramps. My periods are so difficult and painful that from the beginning I contemplate suicide to get away from them. I curse the curse! Later when I learn that sex abuse in childhood can be related to hard periods later on, I think, well, if that is true, the abuse must have been horrible, considering the days of writhing I went through each month for thirty years.
But in between periods I am a famous kid! Another friend who has made me famous is named Dr. Pullias. He's an old friend of my Grandpa Bumstead and has property above Sleepy Hollow in the hills. Yes, he is there in the hills, too, along with Uncle and Daddy, but he is never dangerous. He is true and good. I get to know him as a child of ten, but at 13, I send him some postcards that lead to a pen pal relationship, which goes on to be a deep friendship. In letters I tell him all my troubles and all my brags, and he writes back letters of encouragement and counsel. Sometimes I wonder, did he ever have an inkling about Uncle Hersey? What would he have said to me if he'd known that it happened? How would he have helped me? Dr. Pullias, a psychologist, comes along somehow when I need him. He's a professor at USC, a famous man who writes books. I love him for making me famous, too, by sending my writings to an agent, by telling people how wonderful I am, by making me feel as special as anyone possibly could be.
Oh, if only it could have all continued going forward. If only I as Famous Debbie Bumstead could have taken over and gone forward bravely. If only I could have attained my glorious goals – a career with children, a published book or two, a house in a garden, a loving man to love. If only I had not had to stay and watch as sex in its torture mode created another person inside me, born of Little Mary, named Alice. I watch, still sometimes Famous Debbie despite it all, as Alice is thrown down and hurt time after time, year after year. I can hardly bear it.
-Five-
Alice and Tiger
Alice has a whole book written about her, that's how much she is loved by all the parts in me that know her well, including me, Tiger. Tears come to my eyes when I chance to hear her song, “The Theme from a Summer Place,” an instrumental piece that's still often played after 40 years. I hear it in the oddest instances sometimes, once on the gas station muzak, another time on a tv commercial, once at my husband's parents' anniversary party, and so on. As soon as the strains of piano and violin start, I am yearning inside to help Alice, to bring her back to me and somehow undo everything that hurt her and made her disappear.
Alice was beautiful, well-dressed, dynamic, free of inhibition and shyness. As a teen she was wild, super sensitive, everything honest and truthful. As an adult she was vibrant, full of life and teasing laughter. I might have been Alice! Instead I am Tiger, the dullest grown-up imaginable who has calmly taken care of all the troubled characters inside me since my appearance in 1968.
Yes, I, Tiger, was there from the beginning, when Alice first appeared. I came to help her grow into a woman when she was 14. I am a woman, myself, but that's all I am, and that's nothing without Alice. Why am I called Tiger? Just because I'm as far from being a tiger as anyone could be, I am that dull. What Alice and I might have been together, only I and one other person will ever know.
I hardly want to visit it all again for this article on what happened. Here are the bare facts: My mom and dad began a long, long, five, six year long back and forthing, all about his extra-marital affairs, her sadness, the getting back together, the falling apart, and on and on. The things that hurt me the most were Mama's drinking and Daddy's sexuality. The drinking, which lasted five or six years, too, changed my mama into someone different I couldn't trust, who left me alone night after night as she either went out with Daddy or later out with a boyfriend who was a truly terrible drunk. Dad's sexuality was blatant, bringing his girlfriends home, making noisy love to my mom that I had to listen to or see, lecturing me on being tolerant whenever I came back from running away.
I hardly want to remember it.
Why did this affect me so badly? Not only because it would have been hard for any kid, but because it related to the hurt I'd gone through as Little Mary. Even as a six year old I had recognized that Uncle Hersey and my dad looked very alike, spoke alike, laughed, smiled alike. They were practically twins in looks. To have my uncle reveal in secrecy all the sexual deviancy he was so good at, hurting me with its awfulness, and then, just as I was ready to leave that past behind and learn good sexuality, here came my dad, wrecking my heart and mind with this misery of drink and overdone sex.
That's what Alice suffered through. Then she got slammed again when she tried mightily to get back to her own sexual growth. I think because she was scared of sex, she didn't have the skills to find a sexual man. She thought she had. Andrew was a fine fellow, interesting, liking writing and art like Alice did, and they spent hours on the phone, and days on the go together. They even spent nights together. But in the seven years they knew each other he never touched her. In every way they were a couple, yet he didn't kiss her, hold her hand, make love to her. And she didn't know why. She thought it was her fault somehow. But it wasn't her fault. The only thing she should have done that she didn't was ask him about it. What would the answer have been? I don't even know if Andrew knew why he didn't reach out as a man to the lonely Alice of me. When Alice finally hurt enough to realize she must get away from Andrew, more long years of pain followed as she crept into her hideout all alone. How could such a thing happen to such a beautiful girl like Alice? I don't understand it still.
I wrote the book of Alice in 1982 or 3, before I understood consciously what had happened to Little Mary and to Alice. I wrote from my un-named inner unknowable intelligence, which stirs up all that I know with what I've forgotten and a bit of what I will be in the future that I'm still unaware of, and then it makes this magical mishmash into words that actually tell the forgotten past and predict the future with no help from me at all.
Writing The Destruction of Alice was my next attempt at growing, and in it I predicted my cure. Perhaps the cure was obvious and when I stated it out like that, I allowed it to happen. Within a year of writing out how Alice meets a good man in my book, I had met a good man myself, who wanted both to love me and make love to me.
-Six-
Alice by Myself
Never listen to Her. The One called Tiger. She doesn't know a thing. I hate her for all her dull wishy washy ways, trying to take care of me in those days. I didn't need her. I could have escaped and done very well without her around. I might have run away from everyone and started over brand new. How can I know when I've been silenced so completely, mostly by Her?
OK, I know She helped me. She tried. And I know the people of the past who actually did it and hurt me. I never want to know them again. That man called my uncle, haha, I'd never call him uncle. He was nothing more than a drip drop of evil. I don't care what he did. It was nothing to me. I ran away as soon as he appeared. I don't want to know anything about him. That man called my dad, he wasn't my real dad. My real dad would never have done such mean things. I don't care how many times you say that woman who drank those years was my mama, I know she wasn't. My mother would never be a drunk and leave me helpless like that. And what do I care about Andrew. He was good for some fun times, that's all. I didn't care if he made love to me or not. He could be gay for all I care, and he probably was.
I'm alone and I can be alone. I need nothing but my horse to fly away on. First I had my black horse and then my Arabian. They gave me the flyaway feelings of freedom that I needed in those days. Even now I tell Her to go away sometimes, so I can at least imagine myself riding, riding, riding across the fields like I used to do, up the hills. I can go further now, down to the sea, galloping along the beach in the tumbling waves, just like Alex does on the Black Stallion, bareback, no bridle needed, completely free.
Still...most of the time I hardly come out at all. As soon as I do, I'm frightened and I hurry back inside into the deep dark where I'm safe. I got tamed once by Her husband, that was the most I've ever had of life. With him I was free, finally. He tamed me by touching me over and over, as kindly and calmly as if I were a filly needing gentling. He was my everything and now he's gone, wouldn't you know it. Even a good man can leave you, if he dies. That's why I can't stand going on anymore.
Oh, but how free I was with my Phil man. Joyous is the only word that describes my love for him. She, Tiger, had to come in quite often to take care of things, but when She wasn't around, I was as free and full of life as I could be. Phil and I laughed, cuddled, made love in every way from slow and gentle to fast and wild. I didn't need Her for all of that, not like She thought I did. Not with Phil.
But Phil is gone. I'm scared and hidden away again. I want to hug him suddenly in the middle of the kitchen again. I want to tell him all my funny stories while I sit up close on the couch with him, his arm around me. I want to lie quietly with him, held so tight to his chest I know I am safe forever. I want to sing silly songs on the road and watch tv in hotels as we travel together. I want to sit in the cool dawn on the patio with him, knowing I'm loved. But, no, death comes along relentlessly and I have to be alone again. Don't think I can't take it, I can.
But will I ever be let loose to be free and loved again?
-Seven-
Mrs. Debbie Winans
A cure is never as easy as it sounds. I'm Mrs. Debbie Winans, probably the most healthy person inside me, but it took awhile to get here and even so at the least little setback all my other named parts come hurrying back to make me suffer or help me be strong, according to their own experiences. By now there are just too many of me inside me. But each seems to have her own place, if only they'd work together and make me whole.
For several lonely years before meeting Phil, I fell in love with some men. But they didn't return my love at all. Why was I the sort to be “just friends” with a man? After I wrote my Alice book, I let my loved professors read it. One man's comment showed that he understood even more quickly than I did that the ending was about forgiveness and acceptance. Another professor didn't like Alice. He called her a hysterical virgin, which hurt me. But that was perceptive, too, wasn't it?
The battle with Alice and me was desperate during my first months of being with Phil. Alice was afraid. I was determined. She was all for fainting away like Little Mary did, while I was full of love and desire. I wonder if Little Mary felt a darkness overcome her when Uncle Hersey bent his head to her little body with open mouth – because Alice nearly swooned when Phil first clasped me to him and kissed me. I wonder if Little Mary cried after Uncle Hersey hurt her in bed like Alice did when Phil and I first made love. I wonder if Little Mary had trouble sleeping, always in fear of strangers getting her, always jerking awake after falling asleep. That is the trouble Alice had, so badly that Phil often commented on my sudden terrors when we slept together.
So strange all the effects of the past on the present and the future, into the distance future. I was 26 or 27 and still a child in too many ways because I'd not had the chance or taken the opportunity until then to let go and love and fall into danger and find safety instead. Because Phil was a mixture of love, danger, and safety. He cured me eventually. He cured Alice, I should say. He let her and me get over my dad and Andrew, find forgiveness and leave hysterical virginity behind.
So now here I am, Mrs. Debbie Winans, in many ways fulfilled and calm at last. But I didn't consciously know about Little Mary until another 20 years had passed. I thought all my trouble had been from the divorce years and Andrew's betrayal. Though in the 80s when Uncle Hersey was 60 or so the news broke: He had been caught abusing his 3 year old grand-daughter, I still avoided the thought of him for two decades. Then I had a flashing memory come into my mind, and then another, and then another. Little Mary's memories. They came always just as I lay down to sleep at night, specific scenes that horrified my mind and made my stomach feel upset.
Finally I wanted to know. I corresponded with one of my cousins, his daughter, who gave me the history that she herself found out after he'd been caught. He wasn't incarcerated; instead he had to go through counseling. During that time he made his confessions of active lifelong pedophilia with relatives' children and children off the street, any he could find. He took advantage of both boys and girls, but was always careful to hurt them while they were under six, so that they wouldn't remember.
He told my cousin many horrible things about how he did it without penetration, how it all happened. That he himself didn't remember ever being abused as a child, but that he began his own actions as a kid using his little brother, my dad. That he still thought it wasn't a crime, that he was introducing sex to children, helping them learn about it, like men do in primitive tribes where society never makes a big deal of it. But that must all be a lie he told himself, because he was very good at keeping his evil part of life secret. None of the family suspected him, except, my cousin said, maybe his wife later on, but she was too weak to deal with it. But many had had memories haunting them, she, my cousin, two other cousins, daughters of our aunt, who was big sister to Hersey and my dad. Even today, though, some of his five children refuse to think about it, saying at the end, as Uncle Hersey was dying, that he got forgiveness from God.
After learning so much that I thought I'd never know, now I understood what my writing of Alice's pain had been about. Alice had been abused by her uncle. Yet I had thought this idea was metaphorical for me being hurt by Dad's infidelity when I was a teen. Now I see both reality and metaphor were true. It happened.
It happened. That is my title for this article because it has taken me even more years to believe I am right in all that I've written here, including the memories of Little Mary, which, though fictionalized with my imagination, are real. They occurred. It all happened. Don't you think so?
Little Mary: “Yeth.”
True Deborah: “Yes.”
Debbie/Davey: “Yeah.”
Famous Debbie Bumstead: “Yes.”
Tiger: “Yes.”
Alice: “I don't care.”
Mrs. Debbie Winans: “Yes, and Alice does care.”
Alice: “I don't care! I don't care because I hate them all for what they did to me when I didn't deserve it or ask for it or want it.”
“All right, Alice.”
There I am, together yet separate because what happened to me through life splintered me into many pieces, all the pieces of me. You can imagine yourself how important Phil was to me and all the parts of me. He died recently of an illness, leaving me alone after 25 years of life in love.
But my love still remains inside me, and in some ways I'm not even alone. Here are all the pieces of me finally in one article, telling how it happened. That makes me feel whole and together for at least this moment in time. Maybe this moment will stretch into the rest of my life, and I'll be a whole person all at the same time finally.










